Google’s New Policies: A Win for Profits, a Loss for Privacy?
Google’s recent decision to allow fingerprinting for ad tracking has reignited concerns about user privacy, raising serious questions about whether it is prioritising its bottom line over consumer rights.
Despite its previous stance condemning fingerprinting as an unethical tracking method, Google now justifies the change by citing shifts in how people use the internet and the increasing difficulty of targeting ads through traditional means. But privacy advocates argue that this is nothing more than a calculated move to solidify Google’s dominance in digital advertising, with little regard for user control over personal data.
A Reverse on Privacy Commitments?
Back in 2019, Google openly criticised fingerprinting, calling it a practice that “subverts user choice and is wrong.” The company then positioned itself as a leader in privacy-conscious ad technology, championing alternatives like the Privacy Sandbox initiative. Now, Google has changed its tune, effectively greenlighting fingerprinting, a tracking method that is virtually impossible for users to detect, let alone block.
Unlike cookies, which users can clear or block through browser settings, fingerprinting gathers data from a user’s device, including screen size, time zone, language settings, and even battery level, to create a unique identifier. Once collected, this information remains persistent, meaning users cannot erase their digital footprint as easily as they could with cookies. This shift significantly reduces the control individuals have over how their data is collected and used.
Why Has Google Changed its Approach?
Google’s justification for this change hinges on the argument that the digital world is evolving and, therefore, requires new tracking methods. With more users accessing content via smart TVs, gaming consoles, and mobile devices, traditional cookie-based tracking has become less effective. Rather than doubling down on privacy-centric solutions, Google appears to have chosen a path that benefits advertisers, ensuring they can still gather granular user data, even as consumers attempt to opt out.
The digital advertising industry thrives on data, and Google dominates this space with a staggering $200 billion in annual advertising revenue. By allowing fingerprinting, the company ensures that it remains an indispensable force in the market, catering to advertisers who seek more precise targeting capabilities. However, this comes at the direct expense of user privacy, with consumers left with fewer ways to safeguard their personal information.
What Are The Wider Implications?
Privacy experts warn that Google’s new policy will not only benefit advertisers but could also have troubling implications for data security and surveillance. When companies and third parties gain unrestricted access to fingerprinted data, it increases the risk of misuse. Data brokers, surveillance firms, and even law enforcement agencies could exploit these tracking techniques for purposes beyond advertising.
Regulators and watchdog organisations have already condemned the shift, with the UK’s Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) calling fingerprinting “irresponsible” and warning that it significantly diminishes user choice.
This is not the first time Google has faced scrutiny for its handling of user data. The company agreed to pay $391.5 million in 2022 to settle allegations that it continued to track users’ locations even after they opted out of location services. Google has also faced multiple lawsuits over its misleading data collection practices, reinforcing a pattern of prioritising profit over transparency.
The Future of Online Privacy
As Google pushes forward with fingerprinting, the burden falls on regulators, privacy advocates, and users themselves to push back. Policymakers must impose stricter regulations on unclear tracking methods, ensuring that companies cannot exploit loopholes to collect user data without informed consent. Meanwhile, privacy-conscious consumers may need to turn to alternative browsers and tools that actively resist fingerprinting.
How Can Gerrish Legal Help?
Gerrish Legal is a dynamic digital law firm. We pride ourselves on giving high-quality and expert legal advice to our valued clients. We specialise in many aspects of digital law such as GDPR, data privacy, digital and technology law, commercial law, and intellectual property.
We give companies the support they need to successfully and confidently run their businesses whilst complying with legal regulations without the burdens of keeping up with ever-changing digital requirements.
We are here to help you, get in contact with us today for more information.